The privacy regulator ordered quarterly tracker inventories and opt-out tests, after finding FedEx ignored browser signals while saying it did not sell or share data.
California fines Hertz $1.55m and orders quarterly tests of its tags
EditorialBy TrustList Editorial
A second decision orders clothing maker Filson to stop device-based sharing with advertising technology firms within 30 days and pay $217,987, cut because it could not afford more.
- United States
- California
- Sacramento, California
- Regulatory Compliance
- +2 more
About California fines Hertz $1.55m and orders quarterly tests of its tags
California fines Hertz $1.55m and orders quarterly tests of its tags
17 November 2026: California's privacy agency has ordered The Hertz Corporation to pay $1.55 million and to test, every quarter, whether its websites and apps honour the opt-out signals that browsers send on a user's behalf. The CalPrivacy board found that Hertz failed to process those signals, did not tell consumers how it handled them, and put unnecessary friction in the way of opting out.
Not yet independently verified. Both decisions are described as the agency's own announcement gives them. We did not read the decision documents, so the dates of the decisions and the start of Filson's 30-day period are not given here. We will update this when it can be confirmed, and remove this note.
What Hertz must now do each quarter
The remedies read like a work plan for a marketing technology team, and they cover the Hertz, Thrifty and Dollar brands. Every quarter the company must:
- test the methods consumers use to submit requests under the California Consumer Privacy Act;
- keep an inventory of tracking technologies, with a review before any new one is added to a website or app;
- test opt-out compliance in staging and in production, on different browsers and mobile platforms, and for every tag management container.
When Hertz publishes its metrics on privacy requests, it must also report how many opt-out requests arrived as opt-out preference signals.
"They must ensure that consumers' opt-out preferences are passed along and honored," said Lara Kehoe Hoffman, the agency's acting deputy director of enforcement.
Filson told to stop sharing within 30 days
A separate decision concerns CC Filson Co., a maker and retailer of outdoor clothing. Filson must stop all device-based sales and sharing of Californians' personal information to advertising technology companies within 30 days of the decision, and may resume only once it can certify compliance through audits, tests and training.
Its fine is $217,987. The agency says the figure was reduced after Filson's confidential financial information showed it could not pay a multi-million dollar penalty, which tells smaller retailers two things: the starting point for a company of that size was in the millions, and an order to switch off advertising tags can cost more than the fine.
Third opt-out case in a short run
The announcement lists the agency's decision against Federal Express among its recent actions, which we covered in California fines Federal Express $2.975 million. All three turn on the same failure: a browser sent a signal and the site's tags carried on.
The detail in the Hertz order shows where the agency expects the fault to lie. A consent banner can record a choice correctly while a tag in a container nobody has reviewed keeps firing, and a setup that works in one browser can fail in a mobile app. The order's insistence on every container and on both staging and production is aimed at that gap.
Browsers must offer the signal from January
The agency's executive director, Tom Kemp, said it "will use our enforcement authority to stop that behavior in its tracks". The timing matters because the California Opt Me Out Act takes effect in January 2027 and requires browsers operating in the state to offer an easy way to send the signal, so the share of visitors sending one is about to rise.
A company selling to Californians can use the Hertz list as its own test: an inventory of every tag, a review step before a new one goes live, and a quarterly check across browsers, apps and containers that a signal stops the sharing. The agency has not said how many similar investigations are open.
Related on TrustList:
Sources
Categories & features
- United States
- California
- Sacramento, California
- Regulatory Compliance
- Advertising
- Marketing
TrustList Weekly
The week in software and IT, in one email
The news that matters to buyers, new rankings and our own research. Every Thursday, free, and easy to leave.
You may be interested in
The San Francisco and Dubai company says its valuation is up four times on its previous round and that more than 100 businesses use it. The customer results quoted are its own figures.
At least three quarters of the price is cash. DoorDash says it will keep Instacart's enterprise technology for grocers and promises no grocery exclusivity, but closing is not expected before the end of 2027.
The San Francisco company with roots in Kazakhstan does not say how much the extension adds to its DST-led August round. It reports $1 billion in annualised revenue, reached 18 months after launch.
WebKit says Safari and WebKit on iOS, iPadOS, macOS and visionOS 27 cut off network access to identity resolution providers by domain, so marketers who rely on hashed-email IDs lose that signal from Apple users.
The Commission's consumer package would ban dark patterns, force simpler cancellation and human customer service, and give Brussels direct powers with fines of up to 6% of worldwide turnover.
Meta paused the new business terms on 28 October after twice moving their start. The CMA is using Competition Act powers because Meta has no strategic market status, and it can impose interim measures.
The Commission will examine fake listings, phishing that abuses guest data shared with hotels, and whether paid visibility through higher commission is labelled as advertising.
More on TrustList
Everything here links back to the same verified catalogue. Pick your next stop.
- More United StatesThe ranking for this subject
- CompaniesAgencies, consultancies and IT service providers, ranked by verified reviews.
- ProductsSoftware and SaaS with pricing, features, integrations and alternatives.
- AwardsAnnual recognition decided by verified reviews and an independent jury.
- LaunchesNew products and releases, voted up by the community every day.
- AI ModelsBenchmark scores and community ratings for every major model.
- RequestsBuyers describe what they need; vendors respond directly.
- PeopleReviewers, authors and makers with public profiles.
- ComparePut up to four listings side by side before you shortlist.