The Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens has published its final enforcement policy after a consultation that drew 12 responses. Formal cases take nine to eighteen months on average, and the fine power lapses five years after a breach ends.
EU court adviser says striking out legible records is not GDPR erasure
EditorialBy TrustList Editorial
Advocate General Laila Medina says a person can object and ask a church to erase baptism data. The Court of Justice has not yet ruled and is not bound by the opinion.
- GDPR Compliance
- Data Privacy Law
- Belgium
- Regulatory Compliance
About EU court adviser says striking out legible records is not GDPR erasure
EU court adviser says striking out legible records is not GDPR erasure
1 October 2026: An Advocate General at the EU Court of Justice has advised that crossing out a person's details in a register while leaving them readable, and adding a note, does not count as erasure under the GDPR. Laila Medina gave the opinion in Case C-12/25, Bisdom Gent, a dispute over the baptismal register of the Diocese of Ghent.
A Belgian man, baptised as a child, asked the diocese to delete every reference to him from its registers and archives. The diocese struck through his data but kept it legible and recorded his departure from the Church. He complained to Belgium's data protection authority, which ordered erasure, and the diocese challenged that order in a Belgian court, which referred questions to Luxembourg.
Medina first finds that the GDPR applies, because a baptismal register is a structured set of personal data and so a filing system under the regulation. The autonomy of churches does not change that. She considers that the church's processing before the withdrawal request could be lawful even without consent, but that the person may, in principle, ask for erasure by formally objecting.
The church may then keep the data only if it shows compelling legitimate grounds. Administering the sacraments can be one, but it must still be necessary and must outweigh the individual's rights, which is a case-by-case judgment for the national court. If it fails, the church might still rely on archiving in the public interest or historical research, under conditions the opinion sets out.
On method, the opinion says that data must be made illegible to the extent needed so the person is no longer identified or easily identifiable, while the fact that a baptism took place at a given place and time may stay. Pages need not be physically removed. The court's press release records her view that "only a genuine reconciliation of the interests involved can ensure a fair outcome for those concerned".
The Court of Justice is not bound by the opinion and will give judgment at a later date. Any organisation that keeps membership or event registers, and answers erasure requests by annotating or striking through entries, would find this opinion relevant if the Court follows it.
Sources
Categories & features
- GDPR Compliance
- Data Privacy Law
- Belgium
- Regulatory Compliance
TrustList Weekly
The week in software and IT, in one email
The news that matters to buyers, new rankings and our own research. Every Thursday, free, and easy to leave.
You may be interested in
The Garante found the records of one million patients from 800 family doctors could be traced back to individuals. IQVIA has 120 days to comply and says it may appeal.
California’s SB 923, signed on 27 September 2026, extends the CCPA right to delete to personal information a business obtained from third parties and requires online-only businesses to accept requests online. It takes effect on 1 January 2027.
Connecticut’s Public Acts 26-64 and 26-15 take effect on 1 October 2026: limits on pricing with personal data, facial-recognition signage, a ban on selling precise geolocation, AI notices for employees, and data-broker registration by 1 January 2027.
The Commission will examine fake listings, phishing that abuses guest data shared with hotels, and whether paid visibility through higher commission is labelled as advertising.
Providers of high-risk AI systems that follow the CEN and CENELEC quality management standard now get a presumption of conformity with Article 17, more than a year before the high-risk rules apply.
ANPD's guide for IT product and service suppliers explains the "likely access" test, says a company's own claim about user ages does not decide whether the child protection statute applies, and spells out a proactive duty of prevention.
NOK 92 million is the highest fine the Norwegian authority has issued. It rejected Xandr's defence that consent was Grindr's job, and Xandr has three weeks to appeal.
More on TrustList
Everything here links back to the same verified catalogue. Pick your next stop.
- CompaniesAgencies, consultancies and IT service providers, ranked by verified reviews.
- ProductsSoftware and SaaS with pricing, features, integrations and alternatives.
- AwardsAnnual recognition decided by verified reviews and an independent jury.
- LaunchesNew products and releases, voted up by the community every day.
- AI ModelsBenchmark scores and community ratings for every major model.
- RequestsBuyers describe what they need; vendors respond directly.
- PeopleReviewers, authors and makers with public profiles.
- ComparePut up to four listings side by side before you shortlist.