The complaint also names Criteria's cognitive, personality and AI video interview tools, and arrives while Workday still faces a California discrimination case over its screening software.
EEOC moves to withdraw its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records
EditorialBy TrustList Editorial
The rule went to the White House for review on 6 October, and employment lawyers say employers still face Title VII risk if a background policy hits one group harder.
- United States
- Employment Law
- Employment Screening
- Background Screening
About EEOC moves to withdraw its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records
EEOC moves to withdraw its 2012 guidance on arrest and conviction records
8 October 2026: The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has sent a final rule to the White House that would rescind its 2012 enforcement guidance on how employers use arrest and conviction records in hiring. The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs lists the rule, RIN 3046-ZA04, as received on 6 October and pending review. HR Dive reports that neither the review timetable nor the date the guidance would actually disappear is known.
Not yet independently verified. We have seen the White House review listing but not the rule text. HR Dive says EEOC did not respond to its request for comment, and no timetable for the rescission has been given. We will update this when it can be confirmed, and remove this note.
The 2012 document, "Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions under Title VII", set out three factors for employers: the nature and gravity of the offence, the time since the offence or the end of the sentence, and the nature of the job. It also said an arrest does not establish that criminal conduct occurred, and it warned that a blanket exclusion could produce a disparate impact because some groups are arrested and incarcerated at higher rates.
The move follows an executive order signed in April 2025 that told the attorney general and the EEOC chair to re-examine investigations, lawsuits and positions built on disparate-impact liability. The Department of Labor issued a final rule in July removing disparate-impact liability from its own antidiscrimination regulations, and HR Dive notes the Department of Justice has said the EEOC's earlier disparate-impact guidelines are unconstitutional.
Lawyers at Littler, quoted by HR Dive, cautioned against reading the change as a licence. Employers that apply a criminal background policy more harshly to one protected class than another will likely still violate Title VII, in their view, and the EEOC can still investigate. Disparate-impact claims are also written into Title VII, so private plaintiffs can keep bringing them whatever the agency does.
For teams that run screening through software, the Littler warning is the part to act on: a policy that hits one group harder stays a Title VII risk. Our background check software category lists seven products.
Related on TrustList:
Sources
Categories & features
- United States
- Employment Law
- Employment Screening
- Background Screening
TrustList Weekly
The week in software and IT, in one email
The news that matters to buyers, new rankings and our own research. Every Thursday, free, and easy to leave.
You may be interested in
The regulator reprimanded Lexbase and Krimfup over criminal-record data and MrKoll and Upplysning over erasure requests, ruling that their constitutional publishing certificates do not override EU law.
Cognizant, Infosys, Tata, Wipro, HCL and Capgemini are named as outsourcers; Microsoft and Adobe are cited for active federal investigations. Duration and effect on pending cases were not stated.
Of 80 items tagged to North America, 17 record a government asking something of businesses; only 8 carry a date, and 4 of those fall on 1 January 2027.
Tipped workers move to a $9.85 cash wage. The rate covers only contracts signed from 2015 to January 2022 and not renewed since, and starts on 6 January 2027.
Governor Newsom signed SB 947, SB 951, AB 1331 and AB 1883 on 30 September 2026: employers may not rely only on AI to discipline or fire, must disclose when AI causes a mass layoff, and face new limits on workplace surveillance.
The government accepted all six recommendations of its senior employment workgroup, including a Flexi-Load Programme from 2028 and a Re-Employment Credit. Grant amounts and rules come in the first half of 2027.
Decree DS 020-2026-TR covers seven departments and Callao on different days. Private employers opt in by agreement with staff, every hour off must be worked back, and tax deadlines do not move.
More on TrustList
Everything here links back to the same verified catalogue. Pick your next stop.
- More United StatesThe ranking for this subject
- CompaniesAgencies, consultancies and IT service providers, ranked by verified reviews.
- ProductsSoftware and SaaS with pricing, features, integrations and alternatives.
- AwardsAnnual recognition decided by verified reviews and an independent jury.
- LaunchesNew products and releases, voted up by the community every day.
- AI ModelsBenchmark scores and community ratings for every major model.
- RequestsBuyers describe what they need; vendors respond directly.
- PeopleReviewers, authors and makers with public profiles.
- ComparePut up to four listings side by side before you shortlist.