The French regulator's final recommendation covers the vendors that build replay tools and the sites that run them. No exemption applies, purposes must be set before collection, and mouse movement should be masked where login codes are typed.
CNIL asks email senders how its tracking pixel rules are working
EditorialBy TrustList Editorial
France's data protection authority wants concrete and, where possible, costed answers from senders and email tool providers by 3 December, seven months after its recommendation on tracking pixels.
- France
- Paris, France
- Email Marketing
- Consent Management
- +2 more
About CNIL asks email senders how its tracking pixel rules are working
CNIL asks email senders how its tracking pixel rules are working
20 November 2026: The CNIL, France's data protection authority, has opened a call for feedback on its recommendation on tracking pixels in emails, asking private-sector senders and the companies that supply their email tools to report what has changed. Contributions are open until Thursday 3 December 2026.
Not yet independently verified. This rests on the CNIL's own page in French, dated 20 November 2026 and read the same day; the page does not say whether that is its publication or update date. We have not reread the full 14 April recommendation for this item. We will update this when it can be confirmed, and remove this note.
The rule being reviewed
A tracking pixel is the invisible image in a marketing email that tells the sender when, and often where, a message was opened. The CNIL published its recommendation on these pixels on 14 April 2026, after a public consultation that closed on 24 July 2025. Its page restates how the rule is phased in. New contacts must be handled in line with the recommendation from the start. For databases built up before it, senders must clearly tell recipients within three months that pixels are used, so that those recipients can object.
What the CNIL wants to hear
The call is a first review of the recommendation in practice, not a new draft. The CNIL lists the questions it wants answered:
- whether the recommendation actually protects the people receiving emails;
- what difficulties senders have met and what good practice has emerged;
- the effects on compliance costs;
- how audience measurement and personalisation have changed;
- what alternatives the market now offers.
It asks for answers that are "précis, concrets et, dans la mesure du possible, chiffrés", precise, concrete and where possible quantified, with particular attention to economic sustainability. Organisations are asked to consolidate their replies into one response, submitted through the online form linked from the page.
Why email tool vendors are named
The call is addressed to solution providers as well as senders, and that is where most of the hard data sits. Open rates, consent rates and the share of contacts who objected after being informed are all held in the sending platform, not in the marketing team's spreadsheets. A vendor that can show how its customers' measurement changed is in a stronger position to influence any later revision than one that sends opinions.
For a French sender the practical step before 3 December is to pull those figures: how many contacts were informed, how many objected, and what replaced open-rate tracking where pixels were switched off. Our email marketing software category lists 9 products, and our marketing automation software category another 9, which is where most pixel settings are configured.
Related on TrustList:
- CNIL fines Fnac Darty €7m over an app tracker used without consent
- French regulator says session replay tools need prior consent
- Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook's Android gallery access
Sources
- CNIL: Recommandation pixels : retour d'expérience, 20 November 2026
Categories & features
- France
- Paris, France
- Email Marketing
- Consent Management
- GDPR Compliance
- Marketing Automation
TrustList Weekly
The week in software and IT, in one email
The news that matters to buyers, new rankings and our own research. Every Thursday, free, and easy to leave.
You may be interested in
France's regulator found the Fnac app sent browsing history to a third party for product recommendations even after users refused; the companies have one month to prove consent works or pay €10,000 a day.
France's data protection authority has fined an unnamed company EUR 5 million for storing customer passwords in clear text, sharing admin logins between staff and keeping contact-form data for more than 10 years.
APSB26-162 covers code injection, OS command injection and SQL injection in ACC v7 on Windows and Linux; one SQL injection needs no login. Build 9403 fixes all eight, and Adobe knows of no exploitation.
Nine CVEs land at once in the open-source marketing automation platform. The worst lets any user allowed to import campaigns place a script in the web root of a 7.x install.
Twilio’s Heightened Awareness Period runs from 19 November 2026 to 4 January 2027: US sending rates for toll-free, short code and 10DLC may be limited per account, and high-volume short code and toll-free senders may move to Market Throughput.
The Garante says the gallery suggestions feature, on by default since 2023, read photos and videos of about 20 million Italian Android users without specific consent. Meta has 60 days to change it.
Deutsche Telekom's T.Capital Tech Fund has invested EUR 100 million in Mistral AI's Series D round as a first step towards a partnership to bring Mistral's models to German companies and public bodies on Telekom infrastructure.
More on TrustList
Everything here links back to the same verified catalogue. Pick your next stop.
- More FranceThe ranking for this subject
- CompaniesAgencies, consultancies and IT service providers, ranked by verified reviews.
- ProductsSoftware and SaaS with pricing, features, integrations and alternatives.
- AwardsAnnual recognition decided by verified reviews and an independent jury.
- LaunchesNew products and releases, voted up by the community every day.
- AI ModelsBenchmark scores and community ratings for every major model.
- RequestsBuyers describe what they need; vendors respond directly.
- PeopleReviewers, authors and makers with public profiles.
- ComparePut up to four listings side by side before you shortlist.